![1923 Is This Couple Someone We Can Trust [The Dutton Rules]](https://bigcountry975.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/1923-Is-This-Couple-Someone-We-Can-Trust-The-Dutton-Rules.png)
The second season of 1923, the popular Yellowstone prequel series, continues to keep fans on the edge of their seats. In Episode 5, titled Only Gunshots to Guide Us, Alex finds herself in serious trouble once again. This time, her journey by train takes a dangerous turn. But help comes from an unexpected source — a British couple named Hillary and Paul.
While the two appear kind and helpful, fans are still unsure if they can be fully trusted. In the unpredictable world of 1923, kindness often comes at a price. So, will Hillary and Paul turn out to be true allies or secret enemies?
Who Are Hillary and Paul in 1923?
Hillary and Paul are introduced in Episode 5 as a polite and well-mannered British couple. They are travelling on the same train as Alex, who is headed to Chicago. Due to her difficult situation, Alex is forced to work on the train in exchange for food.
After a meal, the couple learns that Alex is also British and quickly warms up to her. The next day, a horrifying event takes place — Alex is sexually assaulted. Hillary and Paul witness it and step in to support her. When the police doubt her story, the couple vouches for her and helps get the attacker arrested.
Hillary is played by Janet Montgomery, known for her role in New Amsterdam, while Paul is played by Augie Prew, who has acted in Rings of Power and Prison Break.
What Happens Next for Alex?
After the assault, Alex finds herself alone again. Her train connection is canceled due to a snowstorm, and she’s left stranded at a busy train station. Just as she begins to panic, Hillary and Paul return and offer her a place to stay at their home in Winnetka, a wealthy area near Chicago. She agrees, having little choice.
While their kindness seems genuine, many fans remain cautious.
Can Viewers Trust Hillary and Paul?
The Dutton Rules podcast team discussed this new couple in detail, including how their actions could affect Alex’s journey. While some fans believe Hillary and Paul are simply kind-hearted people trying to help, others feel there’s more to the story.
One YouTube commenter said, “I liked them. They seemed genuine.” But another wrote, “The nicer someone is in this universe, the less you can trust them.”
This kind of suspicion isn’t new in the world of Yellowstone and 1923. Viewers have seen time and again how good intentions often come with hidden motives. Some believe Hillary and Paul might become helpful allies, offering Alex support or money to continue her journey to Montana. Others think they may be connected to Donald Whitfield, the show’s main villain, and could betray her.
What’s Next for Hillary, Paul, and Alex?
It’s hard to say for sure what will happen in Episode 6. Some think Hillary and Paul are just wealthy, friendly people who want to help Alex. Others believe something darker is coming. After all, no one in the Yellowstone universe ever does something for nothing.
One thing is clear — Alex’s troubles are far from over. Whether Hillary and Paul turn out to be friends or foes, the next episode is sure to bring more twists.