These 7 Important Questions Were Never Answered in “1923,” So We Will [Dutton Rules]

The second season of 1923, the prequel to Yellowstone, has come to an end, but fans are still talking. While many people were happy with the way the story wrapped up, others are left wondering about a few surprising twists.

Questions like “Did Spencer Dutton really have another child?” or “What happened to Elizabeth’s baby?” are still on everyone’s mind. Some cast members have shared small clues, and fans have dug up extra info—but a few mysteries still remain.

Let’s look at the biggest questions that fans are asking after the final episode of 1923 on Paramount+ and try to clear up what we know, and what’s still a mystery.

Will There Be a 1923 Season 3?

As of now, it looks like Season 2 was the final chapter of 1923. The last episode tied up all the major storylines and even jumped ahead to show how things turned out for Spencer Dutton. The story felt complete, with no big cliffhangers or new characters to carry things forward.

Although actor Brandon Sklenar had once hinted that there could be more seasons, later comments from cast member Michelle Randolph (who plays Elizabeth Dutton) suggested the show was done. She said the whole team was sad it was ending, but everyone was ready to continue if asked.

So while there hasn’t been an official cancellation, it’s safe to say there won’t be a Season 3.

Is 1944 the Next Yellowstone Prequel?

Yes, 1944 is supposed to be the next prequel in the Yellowstone universe. However, it may not be the very next show we see. A different show called Madison, starring Michelle Pfeiffer, is already being made and is expected to release in 2025.

Also, the future of 1944 is not fully secure. Paramount, the company behind the series, is being sold, and big changes could happen. There are even rumours that the budgets for creator Taylor Sheridan’s shows could be cut. So while 1944 is planned, it might not come soon—or at all.

Who Is John Dutton’s Grandfather?

There’s some confusion here because of the “Seven Generations” theory. In Yellowstone, John Dutton (played by Kevin Costner) is called a fifth-generation rancher. But if Spencer Dutton is his grandfather, that makes John only fourth-generation.

Here’s the most likely family tree: James Dutton (from 1883) is the first. Then comes his son, Spencer. Spencer’s son would be John Dutton Sr. (possibly the one played by Dabney Coleman in Yellowstone), followed by Kevin Costner’s John Dutton, and then his son Kayce and grandson Tate. That’s six generations, not seven.

Did Spencer Dutton Really Have Another Child?

Yes, and this twist surprised many viewers. Near the end of the series, Elsa Dutton mentions that Spencer had another child with a widow between the events of 1923 and his death in 1969. This line came out of nowhere and wasn’t explained further.

There’s no information yet about this second child or whether they’ll show up in future shows, but this detail feels too important to ignore. Maybe we’ll learn more in 1944 or another spin-off.

Is Elizabeth Still Pregnant?

Yes. Actress Michelle Randolph confirmed that Elizabeth is still pregnant when she leaves Montana for the coast. She says her character promises to write letters but probably won’t return.

It’s unlikely this baby will have a big role in the Yellowstone future. The show didn’t give us much more on what happens to Elizabeth or her child.

Why Did Spencer Blame Donald Whitfield for Alex’s Death?

Alex died from frostbite and infection, not directly because of Donald Whitfield. But Spencer still blames him. He believes everything went wrong because of Whitfield’s attack on the Dutton family ranch.

In truth, Banner Creighton started the trouble when he tried to take revenge on Jacob Dutton. Whitfield only joined in later by giving Banner money and power.

Still, grief can twist someone’s view of events. Spencer wanted someone to blame—and Whitfield became that person.

Did Anyone Hear Alex’s Full Story?

Sadly, it seems that Alex’s full story may have died with her. She went through a lot, but only a few people—like Paul and Hillary, the couple from Chicago—knew the details. After their deaths, no one else likely heard everything Alex experienced.

That quiet ending to her journey made the finale even more emotional for fans.

Source