![Carrie Underwood Contains a Dark Side and It Makes Luke Bryan Uneasy [Watch]](https://bigcountry975.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/Carrie-Underwood-Contains-a-Dark-Side-and-It-Makes-Luke-Bryan-Uneasy-Watch.png)
Carrie Underwood is known for her powerful voice, country hits, and cheerful personality. But during the latest episode of American Idol, fans got to see a very unexpected side of her. When a contestant asked the Grammy-winning star about her favourite movies, her answer left both the judges and audience quite surprised—especially fellow judge Luke Bryan.
Carrie’s Shocking Movie Picks
With a big smile on her face, Underwood responded to the contestant’s question with a completely unexpected answer:
“Probably Halloween,” she said confidently.
The contestant was visibly surprised, and so was Luke Bryan, who quickly jumped in, saying, “It’s Carrie’s dark side.”
But Carrie wasn’t done just yet. She went on to list two more horror films among her top favourites.
“I’ve seen all of A Nightmare on Elm Street,” she added. “And the Alien franchises.”
The contestant laughed and admitted, “I really wouldn’t have guessed this from you.”
To that, Luke Bryan jokingly said, “I’m scared to sit by her at this point,” making everyone laugh. His funny reaction clearly showed how unexpected Carrie’s love for horror movies really was.
Fans Get a Glimpse of Carrie’s “Dark Side”
Carrie Underwood is usually seen as sweet, bubbly, and full of positive energy. So when she shared her love for horror films like Halloween, A Nightmare on Elm Street, and Alien, it surprised many viewers. It turns out that the country superstar has a fun twist to her personality—she’s a big horror movie fan!
Whether she enjoys slasher films or sci-fi horror, it’s clear Carrie isn’t afraid of a little thrill. And while some fans found it amusing, others—like Luke Bryan—jokingly wondered just how dark her tastes go. “Does she also watch Dexter or shows about serial killers?” viewers joked online.
A Lighthearted Moment on American Idol
This fun and unexpected moment happened during an episode of American Idol, which now airs on Sundays and Mondays at 8 PM ET, especially as Hollywood Week kicks off. Carrie’s horror movie reveal gave the audience a good laugh and showed just how down-to-earth and fun she really is.
It’s not every day you see a country star who enjoys Freddy Krueger and aliens just as much as romantic comedies or dramas!
