Fans of "1923" Are Certain That This Character Will Die

If there’s one thing Taylor Sheridan’s 1923 guarantees, it’s death and heartbreak. As Season 2 unfolds, fans are bracing for another major character loss before the finale. But who will it be?

A recent fan poll points to one overwhelming favorite—but given Sheridan’s knack for the unexpected, nothing is certain. Let’s explore the top contenders and the cases for their potential demise.

**Who Is Most Likely to Die in 1923 Season 2?**

1. Elizabeth Strafford – The Most Likely to Die

Elizabeth Strafford (Michelle Randolph) has terrible luck, and it doesn’t seem to be improving.

Near-death experiences so far:

Attacked by a mountain lion
Bitten by a wolf
Shot during a gunfight in Season 1
Miscarried her pregnancy

Her string of misfortunes suggests an escalation—could death be next? Fans certainly think so. In a Taste of Country YouTube poll, almost 50% of voters predicted Elizabeth won’t survive Season 2.

Why she might survive:
Since the fan vote leans so heavily in favor of her death, 1923 might throw a curveball and spare her instead.

2. Alexandra – A Tragic Ending?

Alexandra (Julia Schlaepfer) sacrificed a life of royalty to be with Spencer Dutton, but her future looks uncertain.

Challenges she faces:

Pregnant and enduring a dangerous journey to Montana
Separated from Spencer and struggling to reach Bozeman
History repeats: 1883’s Elsa Dutton (Isabel May) was also a strong female lead—who met a tragic end

Fans point out that if Alexandra lived to raise her child in Montana, wouldn’t Yellowstone have mentioned John Dutton’s British grandmother? Her death could explain this gap in the Dutton family’s history.

3. Jack Dutton – Impulsiveness Could Cost Him

Jack Dutton (Darren Mann) is a hothead who never hesitates to charge into danger.

Why he could die:

He’s eager for revenge against the men who attacked the Duttons in Season 1
His reckless nature makes him prone to fatal mistakes
If he dies, the family tree might shift to Spencer’s bloodline

While he’s a crucial part of the 1923 storyline, his impulsiveness could lead him straight into a deadly situation.

4. Spencer Dutton – The Ultimate Shock?

Spencer Dutton (Brendan Sklenar) is a war hero who attracts violence wherever he goes.

Reasons he might not survive:

He’s constantly in danger—enemies are always after him
The Dutton family’s naming patterns hint that he may not be a long-term part of the lineage
Killing off Spencer would be an unexpected, heartbreaking twist—something Taylor Sheridan is known for

However, Spencer feels too important to die just yet. His journey to Montana is a major part of the show, and he may have unfinished business.