Wrestling fans in Shreveport, get ready! The one and only Scott Steiner, also known as Big Poppa Pump, is coming to town for Geek’d Con’s 10th Anniversary this August. Whether you remember his wild promos or his unmatched strength in the ring, there’s no denying that Steiner is one of pro wrestling’s most memorable stars.
Before he makes his appearance at the fan convention, why not take a trip down memory lane and revisit some of his best matches ever? These are handpicked based on ratings and reviews from Cagematch.net, a fan-driven wrestling database that keeps track of match ratings, reviews, and more — some reviews going back over 10 years!
3. Steiner Brothers vs The Hart Brothers (WWF Wrestling Challenge, 1994)
Coming in at number three is a classic tag team match between two legendary wrestling families: The Steiner Brothers and The Hart Brothers. This match aired on WWF Wrestling Challenge on January 11, 1994.
According to fans on Cagematch.net, this tag team battle scored an 8.31 out of 10. Only one reviewer gave it a low score, while the rest praised the intensity, athleticism, and raw strength on display. Even though some fans weren’t thrilled with the match’s ending, most agree it’s a must-watch for fans of old-school tag team wrestling.
Finding this match might be tricky, though. It’s not available in WWE’s official library on Peacock, so unless you’ve got a VHS trader buddy, it might take some digging to track down.
2. Hiroshi Hase & Keiji Muto vs The Steiner Brothers (NJPW Battlefield, 1994)
At New Japan Pro Wrestling’s Battlefield event held on January 4, 1994, the Steiners faced off against Japanese wrestling legends Hiroshi Hase and Keiji Muto. This event is often called Japan’s version of the Super Bowl — a big deal for any wrestler.
This hard-hitting match earned an 8.33 out of 10 on Cagematch.net, making it the second-best match of the entire event. Reviewers praised the pace, physical storytelling, and technical work. It’s a perfect example of American power meeting Japanese precision.
Want to watch this match? All you need is a subscription to NJPW World, which costs about ₹800 ($9.99) per month. If you enjoy Japanese wrestling or want to see the Steiners in their prime, it’s well worth it.
1. Steiner Bros, Brian Pillman & Sting vs The Four Horsemen (WCW WrestleWar 1991)
At the top of the list is the legendary War Games match from WCW WrestleWar 1991, where the Steiner Brothers teamed up with Brian Pillman and Sting to take on the dangerous Four Horsemen (Ric Flair, Larry Zbyszko, and Barry Windham).
Rated 8.35 out of 10 on Cagematch.net, fans consider this match Scott Steiner’s greatest performance. Some even compare it to the intense “Kings Road” style of All Japan Pro Wrestling, known for its emotional storytelling and hard-hitting action — a huge compliment in wrestling circles.
This match is easily available on Peacock, along with the full WCW archive, so you can rewatch this classic anytime.